Valentine’s Day Outfits That Are Not Too Much, Not Too Little, but Just Right

If you’d like your outfit to do the talking, this button-up is subtly embroidered with “I love you” on the pocket and the hem. It’s slightly cropped so it’ll pair nicely with your favorite pair of high-rise jeans. ($118, Anthropologie)

This sleek maxi is made of soft and stretchy organic cotton, so whether you’re enjoying a four-course tasting menu or dancing with your girls, you’ll feel good. The Wine Tasting Red is perfect for the occasion. ($60, Quince)

If you’re spending the night watching Tell Me Lies (just us?), you deserve a new pajama set. It has pink hearts all over and cute details like a ruched waist and ruffles on the collar. We can’t think of a better way to show yourself some love. ($128, Hill House Home)

Yes, you read that right. Unlike the push-up bras of your teenage years, this one is wire-free, so nothing is digging in as the foam cups give you a little lift. It won’t show, even under the tightest of tees, and the cherry red is particularly alluring. ($68, Knix)

Invest in this classic silk dress that’ll become your new wardrobe staple. You can layer a turtleneck underneath for a chic dinner date vibe or throw on a heart necklace to lean into the holiday. You’ll wear it to a spring wedding in a few months. ($248, Reformation)

Slip these on to make a movie night feel special, or if you’re hitting the town, layer them over tights with a chunky sweater. You’ll wear the pink or red ones even after the holiday is over. ($50, Free People)

You can’t beat the look of a perfect-fitting cardigan. It’s sleek, festive in the red, and this one won’t cost you an arm and a leg. They also have a crewneck version we own and love. ($79.90, Quince)

I wore this dress for Christmas dinner, and it fits even better than you can imagine. The V-neck is pretty but not so low that I felt uncomfortable or couldn’t wear a bra, and the slip-like skirt is body-skimming without being too clingy. I’ll be pulling it out for my Valentine’s Day plans, for sure. ($298, Saks Fifth Avenue)

Too often pink and red together come off as kitschy, but this polo sweater says otherwise. Maybe it’s the hint of brown worked into the striped pattern, or maybe it’s the retro style. Either way, Staud has knocked it out of the park again. ($175, Nordstrom)

If your Valentine’s Day consists of running errands — coffee, nails, and Target count — then hitting the couch, this mockneck crew is perfect for both. It comes in a cute pink color and has matching sweatpants. ($65, Abercrombie & Fitch)

There’s something so grown sexy about an off-the-shoulder top. Pair this one with leather pants and heels for an effortless date night ’fit. Since you’re essentially stepping out in a cozy sweater, you’ll be comfortable no matter your plans. ($97, Revolve)

If a pink or red top is a little too on the nose for you, stand out by opting for a pair of red trousers. The possibilities are endless for what you can pair them with, from a white turtleneck to a blazer with just a bra underneath. ($71, Gap)

Does this maxi dress have frills, polka dots, and a bow? Yes, yes, and yes. But somehow it still works without being too cheesy, especially if your plans involve a bottle of wine and your best friends. ($289, Urban Outfitters)

I have this dress in black (it’s sold out), and when I bought it, I had no idea I would wear it so much. You can put a long-sleeve shirt underneath it to make it a little less revealing (and chilly). I love the idea of wearing chocolate brown instead of the typical colors. ($99.90, Zara)

Whether you’re going on a first date or grabbing a casual burger with your partner, a turtleneck will never not be chic. Dress it up or down, but either way it’s giving, “I look impossibly put-together, even though I didn’t put much thought into it.” ($24.49, Old Navy)

Not only is this waffle-knit long-sleeve comfy for lounging around the house, but you’ll also look cool wearing it out of the house since sportswear is trending. If you’re not the holiday’s biggest fan, this top will help you express it. ($110, Nordstrom)